In my opinion, there are 4 clear 1st team All-Americans, who's the 5th in your opinion;
1 Mason Plumlee
2 Trey Burke
3 Doug McDermott
4 Cody Zeller
(Bennett, Canaan, Carter-Williams, Withey, etc.????)
Anthony Bennet and Shabazz Muhammed have both breathed new life into their storied programs and should be in strong consideration if not a lock to be on the first team all american.
Also I would put Whithey on there before McLemore, Whithey has been outright dominant this year.