[mikeyvthedonParticipant]

I will credit to mikenike and gatorsheels for making these GOOD comparison lists and not just asking about one pairing and just putting a question mark. I figure that why not do it for actual NBA players. So, let’s rank some guys and just think about which one you would want to take. I guess let’s say you are the GM of your favorite team and you had an opportunity to choose between one or the other, who would you take. I will list the pairings and than put my choice in parentheses. Just want to gauge what people think here, and I will go with similar players, and do it by position. Also, to take out the age argument, lets just say you can have the guy for one year, and than he would leave (Unless otherwise specified).

1. Dwyane Wade vs. Kobe Bryant (Kobe Bryant)
2. Chris Bosh vs. Amare Stoudemire (Amare Stoudemire)
3. Kevin Garnett vs. Tim Duncan (Still like Timmy)
4. Tony Parker vs. Deron Williams (Close call, but I will say Deron)
5. Tracy McGrady vs. Manu Ginobili (Manu)
6. Kevin Durant vs. Carmelo Anthony (Kevin Durant)
7. Caron Butler vs. Rudy Gay (Caron Butler)
8. Jose Calderon vs. Jason Kidd (I like Calderon honestly)
9. Tayshaun Prince vs. Hedo Turkoglu (Tayshaun)
10. Andre Iguodala vs. OJ Mayo (OJ Mayo)
11. Derrick Rose vs. Rajon Rondo (I think Derrick is just better)
12. LaMarcus Aldridge vs. David West (LaMarcus)
13. Elton Brand vs. Carlos Boozer (Still take Elton if he is healthy)
14. Pau Gasol vs. Dirk Nowitzki (Dirk, but I’d like to see others takes)
15. Andris Biedrins vs. Al Horford (Andris Biedrins)
16. Devin Harris vs. Chauncey Billups (Billups)
17. Monta Ellis vs. Allen Iverson (Monta)
18. Vince Carter vs. Joe Johnson (Vince Carter)
19. Michael Redd vs. Richard Hamilton (Rip)
20. Stephen Jackson vs. Kevin Martin (S-Jax)
21. Shawn Marion vs. Ron Artest (Ron-Ron)
22. Michael Beasley vs. Zach Randolph (Beasley)
23. Josh Smith vs. Rashard Lewis (Josh Smith)
24. Kenyon Martin vs. David Lee (Lee)
25. Jermaine O’Neal vs. Shaquille O’Neal (Shaq, still)
26. Nene vs. Chris Kaman (Nene)
27. Marcus Camby vs. Rasheed Wallace (Sheed)
28. Emeka Okafor vs. Andrew Bogut (Emeka)
29. Jason Terry vs. Jason Richardson (J-Rich)
30. Gilbert Arenas vs. Baron Davis (When healthy, Baron Davis)

Now these are ones of straight up pick’em of guys that you would want to stay on your team and who you would want based on future potential. Not necessarily exactly on position either:
1. Greg Oden vs. Andrew Bynum (Oden)
2. Derrick Rose vs. OJ Mayo (Derrick)
3. Andrea Bargnani vs. Charlie Villanueva (Andrea)
4. Al Jefferson vs. Amare Stoudemire (Amare)
5. Al Horford vs. Emeka Okafor (Al Horford)
6. Brandon Roy vs. Kevin Durant (Kevin Durant)
7. Blake Griffin vs. Michael Beasley (Beasley)
8. Russell Westbrook vs. Ricky Rubio (Russell)
9. Johnny Flynn vs. Brandon Jennings (Brandon)
10. Al Thornton vs. Jordan Hill (Thornton)
11. Mike Conley vs. Randy Foye (Randy Foye)
12. Jeff Green vs. Ronnie Brewer (Ronnie Brewer)
13. Yi Jianlian vs. Jason Thompson (Yi Jianlian)
14. Brook Lopez vs. Spencer Hawes (Brook)
15. Anthony Randolph vs. James Harden (Anthony Randolph)
16. Tyreke Evans vs. DeMar Derozan (Tyreke Evans)
17. Kevin Love vs. Joakim Noah (Joakim Noah)
18. Sergio Rodriguez vs. Jordan Farmar (Farmar)
19. JJ Reddick vs. Thabo Sefolosha (Thabo)
20. Adam Morrison vs. Corey Brewer (Stache, I still have some faith)

[birdman1113Participant]

1. Wade
2. Bosh
3. Garnett
4. Williams
5. T-mac
6. Anthony
7. Gay
8. Kidd
9. Turkoglu
10. Mayo
11. Rose
12. Aldridge
13. Boozer
14. Nowitzki
15. Horford
16. Harris
17. Iverson
18. Johnson
19. Redd
20. Kevin Martin
21. Artest
22. Beasly
23. Lewis
24. Lee
25. Shaq
26. Nene
27. Wallace
28. Okafor
29. Terry
30. Arenas

1.Oden
2. Rose
3.Bargnani
4. Jefferson
5. Okafor
6. Roy
7. Beasly
8. Rubio
9. Flynn
10. THornton
11. Foye
12. Green
13. Thompson
14. Hawes
15. Randolph
16. Evans
17. Love
18. Farmar
19. Reddick
20. Morrison

[ckowalskiParticipant]

1.wade – call me crazy
2.bosh
3.duncan
4.parker
5.tracy
6.melo
7.butler
8.kidd
9.prince
10.iggy
11.rose
12.aldridge
13.boozer
14.dirk
15.biedrins
16.chauncey
17.monta
18.vc
19.rip
20.captain jack
21.ron
22.beasley
23.smith
24.kenyon
25.shaq
26.nene
27.camby – never gives up on a play
28.okafor
29.jet
30.baron

1.oden
2.rose
3.charlie
4.amare
5.emeka
6.roy
7.beasley
8.westbrook
9.flynn
10.thornton
11.foye
12.brewer
13.thompson
14.lopez
15.randolph
16.reke
17.noah
18.farmer
19.thabo
20.morrison

[Author]

Posts