Who would you rather have

I would take him too.

Barnes
Knight
Gilchrist

I do not see any as franchise players, but Barnes is clearly the most talented and NBA ready. Also, a good guy, which will get you far.

Barnes, very well rounded player, can do anything on the court, but nothing spectacular

I think barnes is a franchise player mark my words he will be one of the best

I don't know if he has the "IT" factor

Yeah he does read some articles about him he has a never ending work ethic and passion about the game he can score pass rebound he is efficient and is a leader I just hope he comes to Duke

I think Barnes is gonna be an absolute stud, and eventually be a top 2 shooting guard in the league, but everything I've read about Gilchrist gets me excited. He has never ending energy and plays both ends of the floor really hard. Ive heard people compare him to Scottie Pippen, and me being from Chicago, let me tell u that Pippen was a beast and i really do see similar attributes in Gilchrists game, so I would take Gilchrist but its close cause Barnes is the real deal

I'd go with Barnes. I have a hard time seeing Gilchrist being a star in the NBA. I dont see Barnes as a star either, but I think he has more star potential and qualities than Gilchrist.

Barnes

Knight........He can lead a team. When everybody is choking you can depend on him, he is the real deal.

Barnes has all the tools to become a superstar. He can pretty much do anything on the court offensively. But he's no slouch on defense either. I think thats a very underrated part oh his game. Knight and Gilchrist have tones of potential but i dont see them become being better than Barnes. Barnes is a player that can lead a team to victory. The other two will need someone else to help shoulder the load. Hands down Barnes is the player i would rather have on my team.

who cares about these players

Obviously not you so bug off