This topic contains 36 replies, has 13 voices, and was last updated by AvatarAvatar ItsVictorOladipo 11 years, 8 months ago.

  • Author
    Posts
  • #51771
    AvatarAvatar
    druneave3
    Participant

    If you were a General Manager, what would your Top 5 at each position be? In other words, if the NBA started over today with a Fantasy Draft, with everything you know up to this point, what would your big board be for each position? So not really factoring in current talent and ability, but more so, age, potential, the future, and building your franchise to be a title contender for years to come.

    Point Guard

    1. Derrick Rose
    2. Kyrie Irving
    3. Damian Lillard
    4. Steph Curry
    5. Jrue Holiday

    Shooting Guard

    1. Paul George
    2. James Harden
    3. Klay Thompson
    4. Jimmy Butler
    5. Victor Oladipo

    Small Forwards

    1. LeBron James
    2. Kevin Durant
    3. Harrison Barnes
    4. Kawhi Leonard
    5. Danilo Gallinari

    Power Forwards

    1. Anthony Davis
    2. Derrick Favors
    3. Kevin Love
    4. Blake Griffin (not a fan but obviously talented, hopefully D and team play will improve)
    5. Greg Monroe

    Centers

    1. DeMarcus Cousins
    2. Andre Drummond (too much upside on the first two players to pass on, think they both might bust though, still taking that risk)
    3. Jonas Valancuinas
    4. Alex Len
    5. Enes Kanter

    0
  • #832647
    AvatarAvatar
    ProudGrandpa
    Participant

    I feel like Kobe would still be a Top 5 shooting guard. It’s not a deep position and he will certainly help your team be good right away. Would I take Jimmy Butler with a first round pick? No. Would I take Kobe with a first round pick, maybe a 25-30 overall pick? Yeah, I probably would.

    0
  • #832753
    AvatarAvatar
    ProudGrandpa
    Participant

    I feel like Kobe would still be a Top 5 shooting guard. It’s not a deep position and he will certainly help your team be good right away. Would I take Jimmy Butler with a first round pick? No. Would I take Kobe with a first round pick, maybe a 25-30 overall pick? Yeah, I probably would.

    0
  • #832651
    AvatarAvatar
    TheTorontoRaptor
    Participant

    This may be your opinion and I respect it but here is what i think is wrong with this list.

    PG) You don’t even have Russel Westbrook or Chris Paul in your top PG’s list.

    SG) Jimmy Butler and Oladipo are way too high for people who have barely made a big impact in the NBA. DeRozan, OJ Mayo and Wesley Matthews would be better choices for last two.

    SF) No Carmelo

    Id put Rudy Gay or Nicholas Batum somewhere in there instead of harrison barnes kawhi and danilo.

    PF) Anthony Davis and Favors are too high.

    No Lamarcus Aldridge

    C) Dwight Howard? Al Jefferson? Brook Lopez? Gasol?

    Drummond, Valanciunas and Kanter I think will eventually make a list like this but way to early to put them as top 5 centers in a fantasy pool.

    0
    • #832657
      AvatarAvatar
      Mikez
      Participant

      there is nothing wrong with his list, like you said its HIS list.

      0
    • #832763
      AvatarAvatar
      Mikez
      Participant

      there is nothing wrong with his list, like you said its HIS list.

      0
    • #832661
      AvatarAvatar
      druneave3
      Participant

      I should have just said rank players under age 25. Not a popular opinion but for my franchise I would take those PG’s over Russel Westbrook.

      I wouldn’t want to deal with everything that is Dwight Howard. Would rather focus on winning and wouldn’t want that diva, even though I rank Cousins #1. I like Batum but love Barnes, Leonard, Gallo, and think they would help my franchise be closer to winning a title.

      I wish other people would give me their rankings instead of telling me how crazy my opinions are.

      0
    • #832767
      AvatarAvatar
      druneave3
      Participant

      I should have just said rank players under age 25. Not a popular opinion but for my franchise I would take those PG’s over Russel Westbrook.

      I wouldn’t want to deal with everything that is Dwight Howard. Would rather focus on winning and wouldn’t want that diva, even though I rank Cousins #1. I like Batum but love Barnes, Leonard, Gallo, and think they would help my franchise be closer to winning a title.

      I wish other people would give me their rankings instead of telling me how crazy my opinions are.

      0
  • #832757
    AvatarAvatar
    TheTorontoRaptor
    Participant

    This may be your opinion and I respect it but here is what i think is wrong with this list.

    PG) You don’t even have Russel Westbrook or Chris Paul in your top PG’s list.

    SG) Jimmy Butler and Oladipo are way too high for people who have barely made a big impact in the NBA. DeRozan, OJ Mayo and Wesley Matthews would be better choices for last two.

    SF) No Carmelo

    Id put Rudy Gay or Nicholas Batum somewhere in there instead of harrison barnes kawhi and danilo.

    PF) Anthony Davis and Favors are too high.

    No Lamarcus Aldridge

    C) Dwight Howard? Al Jefferson? Brook Lopez? Gasol?

    Drummond, Valanciunas and Kanter I think will eventually make a list like this but way to early to put them as top 5 centers in a fantasy pool.

    0
  • #832659
    AvatarAvatar
    jmarg25
    Participant

    Look, Jimmy Butler is a solid player, but not on a fantasy team. I doubt he ever scores more than 15 points per game. The good things he does don’t show up on a stat sheet. I would have Wade, Derozan, Monta Ellis, and even JR Smith ahead of him, and I could list more.

    0
    • #832771
      AvatarAvatar
      druneave3
      Participant

      Is your franchise trying to win championships or “show up on stat sheets?” Have fun with DeRozan, Ellis, and JR, I’ll take Butler D’ing those guys up, being a team player, making the right play, and trying to win games.

      Not a “fantasy” league.

      0
    • #832665
      AvatarAvatar
      druneave3
      Participant

      Is your franchise trying to win championships or “show up on stat sheets?” Have fun with DeRozan, Ellis, and JR, I’ll take Butler D’ing those guys up, being a team player, making the right play, and trying to win games.

      Not a “fantasy” league.

      0
      • #832815
        AvatarAvatar
        jmarg25
        Participant

        Then make sure you do not make the title of your post “NBA Fantasy Draft”. Sorry for the misunderstanding.

        0
      • #832709
        AvatarAvatar
        jmarg25
        Participant

        Then make sure you do not make the title of your post “NBA Fantasy Draft”. Sorry for the misunderstanding.

        0
        • #832819
          AvatarAvatar
          druneave3
          Participant

          I know those first 3 sentences in my post were quite long, but if you read them, you should realize the main point of the thread.

          People most likely saw the word “fantasy” and said. “hey I know what that is, I have several fantasy basketball leagues.”

          0
        • #832713
          AvatarAvatar
          druneave3
          Participant

          I know those first 3 sentences in my post were quite long, but if you read them, you should realize the main point of the thread.

          People most likely saw the word “fantasy” and said. “hey I know what that is, I have several fantasy basketball leagues.”

          0
  • #832765
    AvatarAvatar
    jmarg25
    Participant

    Look, Jimmy Butler is a solid player, but not on a fantasy team. I doubt he ever scores more than 15 points per game. The good things he does don’t show up on a stat sheet. I would have Wade, Derozan, Monta Ellis, and even JR Smith ahead of him, and I could list more.

    0
  • #832781
    AvatarAvatar
    Lipstick
    Participant

    Judging from the title, I actually thought this meant fantasy basketball instead of, like, actual basketball. It’s probably a good idea to clear up any confusion since there’s a huge difference between the two.

    Anyway, I’d put Russell Westbrook ahead of Jrue Holiday. Westbrook turns 25 in November, so he has plenty of basketball left. I wouldn’t take Chris Paul either though, simply because his body is older than it looks.

    There’s a ton of blue chippers throughout the league, though. It’s understandable to miss a few when making a list like yours, like what about Larry Sanders at center?

    0
  • #832675
    AvatarAvatar
    Lipstick
    Participant

    Judging from the title, I actually thought this meant fantasy basketball instead of, like, actual basketball. It’s probably a good idea to clear up any confusion since there’s a huge difference between the two.

    Anyway, I’d put Russell Westbrook ahead of Jrue Holiday. Westbrook turns 25 in November, so he has plenty of basketball left. I wouldn’t take Chris Paul either though, simply because his body is older than it looks.

    There’s a ton of blue chippers throughout the league, though. It’s understandable to miss a few when making a list like yours, like what about Larry Sanders at center?

    0
    • #832820
      AvatarAvatar
      druneave3
      Participant

      I read the title of 50 Shades of Grey and thought I was getting a book on the visible spectrum.

      The first 3 sentences in my title, if you read it, should clear up the confusion.

      0
    • #832715
      AvatarAvatar
      druneave3
      Participant

      I read the title of 50 Shades of Grey and thought I was getting a book on the visible spectrum.

      The first 3 sentences in my title, if you read it, should clear up the confusion.

      0
  • #832793
    AvatarAvatar
    cryan03
    Participant

    PGs:
    1. Derrick Rose
    2. Russell Westbrook
    3. Kyrie Irving
    4. Steph Curry
    5. Rajon Rondo

    SGs:
    1. James Harden
    2. Paul George
    3. Bradley Beal
    4. Klay Thompson
    5. Kobe Bryant

    SFs:
    1. LeBron James
    2. Kevin Durant
    3. Kawhi Leonard
    4. Carmelo Anthony
    5.

    PFs:
    1. Kevin Love
    2. LaMarcus Aldridge
    3. Al Horford
    4. Anthony Davis
    5. Blake Griffin

    Cs:
    1. Dwight Howard
    2. Brook Lopez
    3. Marc Gasol
    4. Roy Hibbert
    5. Joakim Noah

    0
  • #832687
    AvatarAvatar
    cryan03
    Participant

    PGs:
    1. Derrick Rose
    2. Russell Westbrook
    3. Kyrie Irving
    4. Steph Curry
    5. Rajon Rondo

    SGs:
    1. James Harden
    2. Paul George
    3. Bradley Beal
    4. Klay Thompson
    5. Kobe Bryant

    SFs:
    1. LeBron James
    2. Kevin Durant
    3. Kawhi Leonard
    4. Carmelo Anthony
    5.

    PFs:
    1. Kevin Love
    2. LaMarcus Aldridge
    3. Al Horford
    4. Anthony Davis
    5. Blake Griffin

    Cs:
    1. Dwight Howard
    2. Brook Lopez
    3. Marc Gasol
    4. Roy Hibbert
    5. Joakim Noah

    0
  • #832799
    AvatarAvatar
    Dleg99
    Participant

    Kawhi Leonard had a good finals but he is definitely not better than Paul George, Kawhi is definitely top 10 at sf though

    0
  • #832693
    AvatarAvatar
    Dleg99
    Participant

    Kawhi Leonard had a good finals but he is definitely not better than Paul George, Kawhi is definitely top 10 at sf though

    0
  • #832800
    AvatarAvatar
    apb540
    Participant

    Are contracts being brought into consideration?

    0
  • #832906
    AvatarAvatar
    apb540
    Participant

    Are contracts being brought into consideration?

    0
  • #832802
    AvatarAvatar
    scootover7
    Participant

    Point Guards

    1. Derrick Rose
    2. Chris Paul
    3. Rajon Rondo
    4. John Wall
    5. Stephen Curry

    Shooting Guards

    1. Ray Allen
    2. Kobe Bryant
    3. Dwyane Wade
    4. Tony Allen
    5. Monta Ellis

    Small Forwards
    1. Kevin Durant
    2. Lebron James
    3. Carmelo Anthony
    4. Rudy Gay
    5. Luol Deng

    Power Forwards

    1. Dirk Nowitzki
    2. Kevin Garnett
    3. Blake Griffin
    4. LaMarcus Aldridge
    5. Tim Duncan

    Centers
    1. Dwight Howard
    2. Roy Hibbert
    3. Marc Gasol
    4. DeMarcus Cousins
    5. Joakim Noah

    0
    • #833037
      AvatarAvatar
      ItsVictorOladipo
      Participant

      WTF!!??

      You know who James Harden and Paul George are right?

      smh at the thought of you choosing to build a team with Ray Allen, Tony Allen, or Monta Ellis over Harden

      0
    • #832931
      AvatarAvatar
      ItsVictorOladipo
      Participant

      WTF!!??

      You know who James Harden and Paul George are right?

      smh at the thought of you choosing to build a team with Ray Allen, Tony Allen, or Monta Ellis over Harden

      0
  • #832908
    AvatarAvatar
    scootover7
    Participant

    Point Guards

    1. Derrick Rose
    2. Chris Paul
    3. Rajon Rondo
    4. John Wall
    5. Stephen Curry

    Shooting Guards

    1. Ray Allen
    2. Kobe Bryant
    3. Dwyane Wade
    4. Tony Allen
    5. Monta Ellis

    Small Forwards
    1. Kevin Durant
    2. Lebron James
    3. Carmelo Anthony
    4. Rudy Gay
    5. Luol Deng

    Power Forwards

    1. Dirk Nowitzki
    2. Kevin Garnett
    3. Blake Griffin
    4. LaMarcus Aldridge
    5. Tim Duncan

    Centers
    1. Dwight Howard
    2. Roy Hibbert
    3. Marc Gasol
    4. DeMarcus Cousins
    5. Joakim Noah

    0
  • #832808
    AvatarAvatar
    fennisdembo
    Participant

    How is paul george ranked at sg?
    Do you watch the games? Stephenson and Hill started all year at guard spots.
    When it comes to positions its about defense, who you guard.
    I like the concept of drafting a team now from scratch but too much weight is put on
    Pedestrian positions for the novice fansHow is paul george ranked at sg?
    Do you watch the games? Stephenson and Hill started all year at guard spots.
    When it comes to positions its about defense, who you guard.
    I like the concept of drafting a team now from scratch but too much weight is put on
    Pedestrian positions for the novice fans, come on fellas your better than that

    0
  • #832914
    AvatarAvatar
    fennisdembo
    Participant

    How is paul george ranked at sg?
    Do you watch the games? Stephenson and Hill started all year at guard spots.
    When it comes to positions its about defense, who you guard.
    I like the concept of drafting a team now from scratch but too much weight is put on
    Pedestrian positions for the novice fansHow is paul george ranked at sg?
    Do you watch the games? Stephenson and Hill started all year at guard spots.
    When it comes to positions its about defense, who you guard.
    I like the concept of drafting a team now from scratch but too much weight is put on
    Pedestrian positions for the novice fans, come on fellas your better than that

    0
  • #832823
    AvatarAvatar
    JoeWolf1

    Alex Len before Dwight Howard? This is getting absurd, people should remember this stuff when he drops a 20/14/2.5 season this year.

    0
  • #832929
    AvatarAvatar
    JoeWolf1

    Alex Len before Dwight Howard? This is getting absurd, people should remember this stuff when he drops a 20/14/2.5 season this year.

    0
  • #833035
    AvatarAvatar
    ItsVictorOladipo
    Participant

    Youth is important and I wouldn’t want to have too many guys past their prime if I was creating an NBA team for the future but I also wouldn’t be leaving out guys like Dwight, CP3, Carmelo, LA etc who are still smack dab in their prime

    0
  • #832928
    AvatarAvatar
    ItsVictorOladipo
    Participant

    Youth is important and I wouldn’t want to have too many guys past their prime if I was creating an NBA team for the future but I also wouldn’t be leaving out guys like Dwight, CP3, Carmelo, LA etc who are still smack dab in their prime

    0

You must be logged in to reply to this topic. Login